Dr. Dobb's is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.


Channels ▼
RSS

Design

The BMP File Format, Part 1


MAR95: The BMP File Format, Part 1

Once only for Windows, it's now a common format for other platforms

David is a software engineer with Visix Software, makers of the Galaxy Application Framework. He can be contacted via the Internet at [email protected].


The standard format for storing bitmap images in Windows applications is the bitmap (BMP) file format. Sometimes known as device-independent bitmap (DIB), this format is also used by OS/2 programs and many DOS applications. Because of its popularity with Windows applications, however, it is becoming a common format for software on other operating systems as well. Unfortunately, many different file formats claim to be BMP files, some of which are incorrectly structured due to documentation errors in some early editions of the Windows SDK.

Thus, it is common to find BMP files that an otherwise well-written application cannot read. In this two-part article, I'll examine all of the different ways a BMP file can be put together, so that an application can be built that reads all known BMP file formats, plus future formats. The code I'll present assumes nothing about the system it runs on so it should work equally well on DOS, OS/2, UNIX, VMS, or any other operating system.

Throughout this article, I'll use data types such as INT16 and UINT32 instead of the usual short, long, and int because the standard C data types do not have specific sizes associated with them. Table 1 lists these types. In an attempt to keep everything portable, I am not using structures from either the Windows SDK or the OS/2 toolkit. Instead, I have a set of structures which are supersets of both kits. This way, applications using bitmap files (DOS or UNIX programs, for example) can be compiled and run without either toolkit. Table 2 lists my structures and the corresponding Windows and OS/2 structures. Note that the BITMAPARRAYHEADER structure does not exist in the Windows SDK.

In this first installment, I examine the four structures listed in Table 2. Next month, I'll focus on reading and interpreting bits, and discuss how the structures fit together.

Basic Concepts of BMP

Unlike other image-file formats like GIF (CompuServe's Graphic Interchange File format) and JPEG (Joint Photographic Experts Group), the BMP file format was not designed to be portable. Instead, it was designed to easily work with the Windows API using the same structures that Windows applications use to manipulate in-memory bitmaps. As the API changed, so did the BMP file format. Windows now has three documented variants on the BMP file format: one each for Windows 2.x, Windows 3.x, and Windows NT. Additionally, OS/2 has variants designed to work easily with the OS/2 API: one each for OS/2 1.1, OS/2 1.2, and OS/2 2.x, plus one to store its icon (ICO) and pointer (PTR) files.

Fortunately, only two sets of structures are nearly identical. With a little work, you can produce a single set of structures to describe all bitmap files. Figure 1 illustrates the BITMAPFILEHEADER structure; Figure 2, the BITMAPARRAYHEADER structure; Figure 3, BITMAPHEADER; and Figure 4, the RGB structure.

All BMP formats, including the OS/2 icon and pointer variants, are built using these four structures. All use the BITMAPFILEHEADER structure, various subsets of the BITMAPHEADER structure (the size field indicating how much is being used), and the RGB structure. OS/2-format bitmap files containing more than one image also use the BITMAPARRAYHEADER structure.

There is one caveat: The oldest forms of the bitmap file format use 16- instead of 32-bit integers for the width and height fields of the BITMAPHEADER structure. Fortunately, it is easy to tell when such a file is being read, since the size field is always 12 for those structures and greater than 12 for the newer structures. Additionally, files based on the "new" format will add an extra byte to the end of every RGB structure, in order to align it on a 4-byte boundary.

Byte Ordering

The BMP format was designed to work with systems based on Intel processors with their Little-endian byte-ordering scheme. This means that whenever a multibyte field is read (such as a 16- or 32-bit integer), the first byte read will be the least significant, and the last, the most significant. While this isn't an issue when reading the files on Intel processors, it is critical on systems like Sun workstations that use Big-endian byte ordering.

To get around these problems, it is a good idea to use functions that are not dependent on byte order when reading and writing fields; see endian.c (Listing One) and endian.h (Listing Two). These functions are used throughout the sample code. They work properly without any conditional compilation statements. They read the bytes individually, combining them arithmetically to produce the required multibyte integer. The resulting integer will be correctly formatted for the host processor. Similarly, writing is performed by decom-posing the integer arithmetically and writing the bytes individually, least-significant byte first.

These functions also help work around problems arising from differences between 16/32/64-bit processors. On a 64-bit processor (such as an Alpha-based system), the size of a short integer will be 32 bits instead of the usual 16. Reading and writing the files on a byte-by-byte basis avoids problems that can arise from these differences.

Reading the Structures

Each of the structures, BITMAPFILEHEADER, BITMAPARRAYHEADER, BITMAPHEADER, and RGB, is involved in reading a bitmap file. Each structure may be read by calling the appropriate Little-endian-value read function on each field. The fields are ordered as they appear in the structure definition.

That's all that's required to read BITMAPFILEHEADER and BITMAPARRAYHEADER structures. Both structures are of a fixed length, so reading them simply involves reading each field.

The BITMAPHEADER and RGB structures, however, are more complicated. Both are variable-length structures, and therefore require special handling when reading. The BITMAPHEADER structure contains its length as the first field. The RGB structure is often stored with an extra byte of padding when used in color tables.

The readBitmapFileHeader, readBitmapArrayHeader, readBitmapHeader, and readRgb functions in readbmp.h and readbmp.c show how to properly read these structures. (These files are available electronically; see "Availability," page 3.)

Reading the BITMAPHEADER Structure

The BITMAPHEADER structure contains all the information required to describe a bitmap (see Figure 3). It is a 64-byte long structure containing many fields. But most bitmap files do not use all of the fields, so how do you know how many are used and how many are not?

The answer is the size field, which always contains the length (in bytes) of the BITMAPHEADER structure. If only the first 16 bytes are used, then only they are stored in the file, and the size field will contain the value 16. If all 64 bytes are used, then all 64 bytes are stored in the file and the size field will contain the value 64.

The smallest value for the size field is 12 bytes. This is a special case--only the "old" format bitmap files will have a BITMAPHEADER structure 12 bytes long. When reading these old format bitmaps, the width and height fields must be read as 16-bit integers instead of the usual 32-bit integers.

When reading the BITMAPHEADER structure, you must keep count of the number of bytes read, since the structure can be any length (even greater than 64). After reading the number of bytes indicated by the size field, the structure has been completely read. Any fields in the structure that have not been read should be initialized to 0. If the entire structure has been read and the count is still less than the value contained in the size field, then there are extra bytes on the disk, since the meaning of these extra bytes is unknown.

Color Tables

Immediately following every BITMAPHEADER structure is a color table. For most bitmaps, it is an array of RGB structures. When reading the pixel values of such a bitmap, each pixel's value will be an index into this array indicating the color that value represents. This is not the case only when BITFIELDS compression is used; then, the table has special meaning.

For bitmaps with normal color tables (where the compression scheme is not BITFIELDS encoding), the length of the color table is a function of the number of colors the image can have. The number of possible colors is 2bit depth, where bit depth is the number of color planes, multiplied by the number of bits per plane. If bit depth is 24, however, the length of the color table is 0, since each pixel will already contain the proper RGB value.

Each entry in a normal color table is one RGB structure. The first byte is the blue value; the second, green; and the third, red. If this is a "new" format bitmap (indicated by the image's BITMAPHEADER structure having a size greater than 12 bytes), then an additional byte of padding between each RGB structure must be skipped over before reading the next structure in the array.

The readColorTable function (see readbmp.h and readbmp.c, available electronically) shows how to properly read a normal color table.

Understanding the BITMAPFILEHEADER Structure

The BITMAPFILEHEADER structure (Figure 1) always appears on disk immediately before a BITMAPHEADER. It indicates what type of image the BITMAPHEADER describes, points to the bitmap's pixel data, and (in the case of OS/2 pointer files) indicates where the pointer's hot spot is. For a single-image file, the first structure in the file will be a BITMAPFILEHEADER. For a multiple-image file, the first structure will be a BITMAPARRAYHEADER, and each image will have its own BITMAPFILEHEADER.

The first field, type, indicates what type of image the following BITMAPHEADER describes. Table 3 contains the field's possible values. Note how each numeric value can also be interpreted as two characters, which are a mnemonic describing the image type.

The next field of the BITMAPFILEHEADER, size, can be safely ignored. It is a count of bytes used for the BITMAPFILEHEADER combined with the subsequent BITMAPHEADER. Using this field for anything is dangerous, though. Windows and OS/2 have different definitions for the field. Windows defines it as the size of the entire bitmap file (in DWORDs), while OS/2 defines it as the size of the BITMAPFILEHEADER, plus the size of the following BITMAPHEADER structure (in bytes). Many bitmap files simply store 0 in this field. Fortunately, the BITMAPHEADER contains its own size field, so this one can be ignored.

The next two fields are the x and y coordinates for the hot spot. For TYPE_BMP images, this value is ignored (and those two fields are documented as "reserved" in the Windows SDK, where this structure is only used for BMP files). For the other four image types, these two values contain the position where the hot spot should be if the image is used as a mouse pointer. The coordinate is relative to the lower-left corner of the image.

The fifth and last field, offsetToBits, contains the byte offset (from the start of the file) to the first byte of the image's color data. The interpretation of this data varies depending on the contents of the BITMAPHEADER that follows.

Understanding the BITMAPARRAYHEADER Structure

The BITMAPARRAYHEADER structure is used to establish a linked list of images in a multiple-image bitmap file. Because only OS/2 supports the multiple-image bitmap file, Windows applications often crash when a bitmap file using this structure is loaded. A BITMAPFILEHEADER always follows immediately after every BITMAPARRAYHEADER structure.

The first field of a BITMAPARRAYHEADER structure is the type field and always contains the hexadecimal value 0x4142 ('BA'). This value has the symbolic name TYPE_ARRAY.

Although it seems redundant with only one possible value, the type field serves an important purpose. Since a file can begin with either a BITMAPARRAYHEADER or a BITMAPFILEHEADER structure, the type field, which appears first in both structures, can be used to determine which of the two structures the first structure is.

The second field, size, serves a similar purpose to the size field in the BITMAPFILEHEADER. In other words, it can be safely ignored.

The third field, next, is a pointer to the next BITMAPARRAYHEADER in the linked list. Its value is the byte offset from the start of the file where the next BITMAPARRAYHEADER begins. It will contain 0 if this is the last image in the list.

The last two fields, screenWidth and screenHeight, define the device on which this image should be displayed. If they contain 0s, then the image is device independent; otherwise, it is intended for a screen with a height and width (in pixels) that matches these fields. OS/2 multiple-image bitmaps usually contain the same picture, rendered with different dimensions and/or colors. When using a multiple-image file, proper procedure is to pick the image whose screenWidth and screenHeight fields match the output device's size. If there are no matches, the first image in the file is normally used. Device-independent images (with screenWidth and screenHeight values of 0) should always be the first images in a file.

Understanding the BITMAPHEADER Structure

The BITMAPHEADER structure is at the core of every image in a bitmap file. Although it contains 19 fields, many of them can be safely ignored. As a matter of fact, most images will contain 0s (default values) for all but the first five fields.

The first field, size, is used to determine the size of the structure on disk. The next two fields, width and height, indicate the dimensions (in pixels) of the image. It should be noted that height can be negative, in which case it uses an inverted coordinate system (an upper-left origin instead of the usual lower-left). In this case, the actual height of the image is the absolute value of the height field.

The next two fields, numBitPlanes and numBitsPerPlane, indicate color depth. numBitPlanes is nearly always 1--Windows only supports single-plane bitmaps, and all of OS/2's standard bitmap formats are single plane. numBitsPerPlane is the bit depth for a single-bit plane. Multiplying these two values together yields the image's bit depth, usually 1, 4, 8, or 24. Windows 3.x supports bit depths of only 1, 4, and 8. Windows NT supports 1, 4, 8, 16, 24, and 32. OS/2's standard bit depths are 1, 4, 8, and 24, although any depth from 1 through 24 is theoretically valid.

The next field, compressionScheme, indicates whether the image's pixel data has been compressed. Most bitmaps are uncompressed, but some use RLE compression; Table 4 lists the possible values. Note that the value 3 indicates both modified Huffman compression and BITFIELDS encoding. OS/2 interprets the value as modified Huffman compression, while NT reserves it for BITFIELDS. This is not a problem, however, since the BITFIELDS layout is only used for 16- and 32-bit-per-pixel images and modified Huffman encoding is only used for monochrome (1-bit-per-pixel) bitmaps.

The sizeOfImageData field is the number of bytes an image's pixel data consumes. The start of the data is pointed to by the offsetToBits field in the BITMAPFILEHEADER structure. This field is normally 0 if the compressionScheme is COMPRESSION_NONE, in which case, the size is calculated from the width, height, and bit depth of the image.

For most files, the rest of the structure will normally contain 0s. The following fields can be safely ignored without distorting the images:

  • xResolution and yResolution, which contain the resolution (in pixels per meter) of the image. If these values are nonzero, they can be used to generate a scaling factor to print the image at the proper size.
  • numColorsUsed, which indicates the number of colors in the color table actually used by the image. numImportantColors indicates the number of colors required for proper rendering of the image. For both fields, 0s mean "all of them." If numColorsUsed is nonzero, the color table is only that long--additional entries are undefined and may not exist in the file.
  • resolutionUnits, which indicates what units are used for xResolution and yResolution. This field always contains 0, meaning pixels-per-meter and is probably a place holder for future expansion of the bitmap file format.
  • padding, which is unused space, and serves only to align the remaining data onto a 4-byte boundary.
  • origin, which indicates the direction in which the bits fill in the bitmap. It always contains 0, meaning the origin is the lower-left corner. Bits fill in from left-to-right and bottom-to-top. This field, however, is not the only thing that determines the origin of the image. Windows bitmaps do not use this field (the Windows structures stop after resolutionUnits). Windows bitmaps may be stored with an upper-left origin, indicated by storing a negative value for the image's height.
  • halftoning, a flag that indicates one of four halftoning algorithms. The use of these algorithms is undocumented, so I can not provide any additional information. halftoningParam1 and halftoningParam2 are parameters used by the halftoning algorithms; Table 5 lists the possible values.
  • colorEncoding, which describes the format of each entry of the color table. It is always 0, indicating RGB encoding.
  • identifier, the last field in the BITMAPHEADER structure, is not used in describing bitmaps. It contains a 32-bit value for application use.

Understanding the RGB Structure

The RGB structure is rather simple compared to the other structures. It contains three byte values--red, green, and blue--used to describe a single color value. Color tables are an array of these structures.

Until Next Month

That's it for now. In next month's installment, I'll focus on reading and interpreting bits, and discuss how the structures fit together.

Figure 1: The BITMAPFILEHEADER structure.

typedef struct BITMAPFILEHEADER
{
   UINT16    type;
   UINT32    size;
   INT16     xHotspot;
   INT16     yHotspot;
   UINT32    offsetToBits;
}  BITMAPFILEHEADER;

Figure 2: BITMAPARRAYHEADER structure.

typedef struct BITMAPARRAYHEADER
{
   UINT16    type;
   UINT32    size;
   UINT32    next;
   UINT16    screenWidth;
   UINT16    screenHeight;
} BITMAPARRAYHEADER;

Figure 3: BITMAPHEADER structure.

typedef struct BITMAPHEADER
{
    UINT32 size;
    INT32  width;
    INT32  height;
    UINT16 numBitPlanes;
    UINT16 numBitsPerPlane;
    UINT32 compressionScheme;
    UINT32 sizeOfImageData;
    UINT32 xResolution;
    UINT32 yResolution;
    UINT32 numColorsUsed;
    UINT32 numImportantColors;
    UINT16 resolutionUnits;
    UINT16 padding;
    UINT16 origin;
    UINT16 halftoning;
    UINT32 halftoningParam1;
    UINT32 halftoningParam2;
    UINT32 colorEncoding;
    UINT32 identifier;
} BITMAPHEADER;

Figure 4: RGB structure.

typedef struct RGB
{
  UINT8 blue;
  UINT8 green;
  UINT8 red;
} RGB;

Table 1: Basic data types.

Type     Description                                                                 
INT8     Integer at least 8 bits wide
INT16    Integer at least 16 bits wide
INT32    Integer at least 32 bits wide
UINT8    Unsigned INT8
UINT16   Unsigned INT16
UINT32   Unsigned INT32

Table 2: Structures used in bitmap files.

My Structure        Windows Structures     OS/2 Structures          
                                                                    
BITMAPFILEHEADER    BITMAPFILEHEADER       BITMAPFILEHEADER,        
                                           BITMAPFILEHEADER2        
BITMAPARRAYHEADER   (N/A)                  BITMAPARRAYFILEHEADER,   
                                           BITMAPARRAYFILEHEADER2   
BITMAPHEADER        BITMAPCOREINFOHEADER   BITMAPINFOHEADER         
                    BITMAPINFOHEADER       BITMAPINFOHEADER2        
RGB                 RGBTRIPLE, RGBQUAD     RGB, RGB2                

Table 3: Valid BITMAPHEADER types.

Value           Symbolic Name    Description         
0x4D42 ('BM')   TYPE_BMP         Bitmap
0x4349 ('IC')   TYPE_ICO         OS/2 Icon
0x4943 ('CI')   TYPE_ICO_COLOR   OS/2 Color Icon
0x5450 ('PT')   TYPE_PTR         OS/2 Pointer
0x5043 ('CP')   TYPE_PTR_COLOR   OS/2 Color Pointer

Table 4: Compression schemes.

Value   Symbolic name           Description                                    
0       COMPRESSION_NONE        No compression
1       COMPRESSION_RLE_8       8-bit-per-pixel RLE compression
2       COMPRESSION_RLE_4       4-bit-per-pixel RLE compression
3       COMPRESSION_HUFFMAN1D   1-bit-per-pixel modified Huffman compression
3       COMPRESSION_BITFIELDS   16- and 32-bit-per-pixel BITFIELDS encoding
4       COMPRESSION_RLE_24      24-bit-per-pixel RLE compression

Table 5: Halftoning algorithms.

Value   Symbolic name                Description                                                        
0       HALFTONING_NONE              No halftoning
1       HALFTONING_ERROR_DIFFUSION   Error-diffusion halftoning
2       HALFTONING_PANDA             Processing Algorithm for Noncoded
                                       Document Acquisition (PANDA)
3       HALFTONING_SUPER_CIRCLE      Super-circle halftoning

Listing One


/* These functions read and write our basic integer types from a little-endian
 * file. The endian and word-size of the host machine will not affect this
 * code. The only assumption made is that the C data type (char) is one byte
 * long. This should be a safe assumption.
 */

#include <stdio.h>
#include "bmptypes.h"
#include "endian.h"

/*****************************************************************************
* Read functions.  All read functions take an open file pointer as the first
* parameter and a pointer to data as the second parameter.  The return value
* will be 0 on success, and EOF on failure.  If successful, the second
* parameter will point to the data read.
*/

/* The INT8 and UINT8 types are stored as a single byte on disk.  The INT8
 * type is a signed integer with range (-128..127).  The UINT8 type is an
 * unsigned integer with range (0..255).
 */
int readINT8little(FILE *f, INT8 *i)
{
    int rc;
    rc = fgetc(f);
    if (rc == EOF)
        return rc;
    *i = (rc & 0xff);
    return 0;
}
int readUINT8little(FILE *f, UINT8 *i)
{
    int  rc;
    rc = fgetc(f);
    if (rc == EOF)
        return rc;
    *i = (rc & 0xff);
    return 0;
}
/* The INT16 and UINT16 types are stored as two bytes on disk.  The INT16 type
 * is a signed integer with range (-32768..32767).  The UINT16 type is an
 * unisgned integer with range (0..65535).
 */
int readINT16little(FILE *f, INT16 *i)
{
    int rc;
    INT16 temp = 0;
    
    temp = (fgetc(f) & 0xff);
    
    rc = fgetc(f);
    if (rc == EOF)
        return rc;
    temp |= ((rc & 0xff) << 8);
    *i = temp;
    return 0;
}
int readUINT16little(FILE *f, UINT16 *i)
{
    int rc;
    UINT16 temp = 0;
    
    temp = (fgetc(f) & 0xff);
    
    rc = fgetc(f);
    if (rc == EOF)
        return rc;
    temp |= ((rc & 0xff) << 8);
    *i = temp;
    return 0;
}
/* The INT32 and UINT32 types are stored as four bytes on disk.  The INT32
 * type is a signed integer with range (-2147483648..2147483647).  The UINT32
 * type is an unisgned integer with range (0..4294967295).
 */
int readINT32little(FILE *f, INT32 *i)
{
    int rc;
    INT32 temp = 0;
    
    temp = ((long)fgetc(f) & 0xff);
    temp |= (((long)fgetc(f) & 0xff) << 8);
    temp |= (((long)fgetc(f) & 0xff) << 16);
    
    rc = fgetc(f);
    if (rc == EOF)
        return rc;
    temp |= (((long)rc & 0xff) << 24);
    *i = temp;
    return 0;
}
int readUINT32little(FILE *f, UINT32 *i)
{
    int rc;
    UINT32 temp = 0;
    
    temp = ((long)fgetc(f) & 0xff);
    temp |= (((long)fgetc(f) & 0xff) << 8);
    temp |= (((long)fgetc(f) & 0xff) << 16);
    
    rc = fgetc(f);
    if (rc == EOF)
        return rc;
    temp |= (((long)rc & 0xff) << 24);
    *i = temp;
    return 0;
}
/*****************************************************************************
* Write functions.  All write functions take an open file pointer as the first
* parameter and a data as the second parameter.  The return value will be 0 on
* success, and EOF on failure.  If successful, the second parameter will have
* been written to the open file.
*/
int writeINT8little(FILE *f, INT8 i)
{
    return fputc(i, f);
}
int writeUINT8little(FILE *f, UINT8 i)
{
    return fputc(i, f);
}
int writeINT16little(FILE *f, INT16 i)
{
    int rc;
    rc = fputc((i & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
        return rc;
    return fputc(((i >> 8) & 0xff), f);
}
int writeUINT16little(FILE *f, UINT16 i)
{
    int rc;
    rc = fputc((i & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
       return rc;
    return fputc(((i >> 8) & 0xff), f);
}
int writeINT32little(FILE *f, INT32 i)
{
    int rc;
    rc = fputc((i & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
       return rc;
    rc = fputc(((i >> 8) & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
       return rc;
    rc = fputc(((i >> 16) & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
       return rc;
    return fputc(((i >> 24) & 0xff), f);
}
int writeUINT32little(FILE *f, UINT32 i)
{
    int rc;
    rc = fputc((i & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
       return rc;
    rc = fputc(((i >> 8) & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
       return rc;
    rc = fputc(((i >> 16) & 0xff), f);
    if (rc == EOF)
       return rc;
    return fputc(((i >> 24) & 0xff), f);
}
/* Formatting information for emacs in c-mode
 * Local Variables:
 * c-indent-level:4
 * c-continued-statement-offset:4
 * c-brace-offset:-4
 * c-brace-imaginary-offset:0
 * c-argdecl-indent:4
 * c-label-offset:-4
 * End:
 */


Listing Two


/* This is the header for endian.c - functions to read/write our
 * INT8, INT16 and INT32 types from/to a little-endian file.
 */

#ifndef __ENDIAN_H_INCLUDED__
#define __ENDIAN_H_INCLUDED__
 
/* Read the basic types as little-endian values.  The return value will be
 * zero if successful, EOF, otherwise.
 */
int readINT8little(FILE *f, INT8 *i);
int readINT16little(FILE *f, INT16 *i);
int readINT32little(FILE *f, INT32 *i);
int readUINT8little(FILE *f, UINT8 *i);
int readUINT16little(FILE *f, UINT16 *i);
int readUINT32little(FILE *f, UINT32 *i);

/* Write the basic types as little-endian values.  The return value will be
 * zero if successful, EOF otherwise.
 */
int writeINT8little(FILE *f, INT8 i);
int writeINT16little(FILE *f, INT16 i);
int writeINT32little(FILE *f, INT32 i);
int writeUINT8little(FILE *f, UINT8 i);
int writeUINT16little(FILE *f, UINT16 i);
int writeUINT32little(FILE *f, UINT32 i);

#endif  /* __ENDIAN_H_INCLUDED__ */

/* Formatting information for emacs in c-mode
 * Local Variables:
 * c-indent-level:4
 * c-continued-statement-offset:4
 * c-brace-offset:-4
 * c-brace-imaginary-offset:0
 * c-argdecl-indent:4
 * c-label-offset:-4
 * End:
 */


Copyright © 1995, Dr. Dobb's Journal


Related Reading


More Insights






Currently we allow the following HTML tags in comments:

Single tags

These tags can be used alone and don't need an ending tag.

<br> Defines a single line break

<hr> Defines a horizontal line

Matching tags

These require an ending tag - e.g. <i>italic text</i>

<a> Defines an anchor

<b> Defines bold text

<big> Defines big text

<blockquote> Defines a long quotation

<caption> Defines a table caption

<cite> Defines a citation

<code> Defines computer code text

<em> Defines emphasized text

<fieldset> Defines a border around elements in a form

<h1> This is heading 1

<h2> This is heading 2

<h3> This is heading 3

<h4> This is heading 4

<h5> This is heading 5

<h6> This is heading 6

<i> Defines italic text

<p> Defines a paragraph

<pre> Defines preformatted text

<q> Defines a short quotation

<samp> Defines sample computer code text

<small> Defines small text

<span> Defines a section in a document

<s> Defines strikethrough text

<strike> Defines strikethrough text

<strong> Defines strong text

<sub> Defines subscripted text

<sup> Defines superscripted text

<u> Defines underlined text

Dr. Dobb's encourages readers to engage in spirited, healthy debate, including taking us to task. However, Dr. Dobb's moderates all comments posted to our site, and reserves the right to modify or remove any content that it determines to be derogatory, offensive, inflammatory, vulgar, irrelevant/off-topic, racist or obvious marketing or spam. Dr. Dobb's further reserves the right to disable the profile of any commenter participating in said activities.

 
Disqus Tips To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | View the list of supported HTML tags you can use to style comments. | Please read our commenting policy.